Business & Data
Quebec Court of Appeal rules remote work cannot bypass anti-scab law, Unifor says
The court overturned a Superior Court judgment and reinstated an Administrative Labour Tribunal decision in a case involving CRH Canada Group's Joliette cement plant, Unifor Quebec said.
Unifor Quebec said the Quebec Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Unifor Local 177 on Nov. 9, overturning a Superior Court judgment and reinstating an Administrative Labour Tribunal decision in a case involving CRH Canada Group's cement plant in Joliette. The union said the court confirmed that, in the circumstances of the case, remote work cannot be used to circumvent the anti-scab provisions of Quebec's Labour Code.1
The dispute stems from a lockout the employer imposed in June 2021, according to Unifor. During the dispute, the union said, the company used a non-union employee attached to its Joliette establishment to remotely perform duties normally carried out by locked-out members, and the employer argued the prohibition on replacement workers did not apply because the employee was working from home.1
Unifor said the Court of Appeal concluded the tribunal could reasonably find the practice violated the Labour Code, because working remotely with the employer's technology and under its authority did not sever the employee's connection to the Joliette establishment.1
An employer should not be able to do behind a screen what the law prohibits it from doing in its workplace.1Daniel Cloutier, Unifor Quebec director
Cloutier said anti-scab protections must remain meaningful in the age of remote work and that the ruling protects workers' bargaining power, and he credited Local 177 with leading the fight.1
Unifor said the court's reasons hold that anti-scab provisions are intended to do more than reduce violence on picket lines: they also aim to restore the balance of power between employers and unions and make collective bargaining fairer by preserving the effectiveness of the right to strike. The court also recognized that tribunals can apply the law to new realities, including remote work, and that the concept of an establishment cannot invariably be confined to the four walls of a building, according to the union.1
This is a major victory for Quebec workers.1Magali Picard, Quebec Federation of Labour president
Picard said the court recognized that when someone works remotely their home becomes a workplace and anti-scab rules apply, and that an employer cannot get around a strike or lockout by assigning bargaining unit work to people working from home. She applauded the tenacity of Unifor and Local 177 members, who she said have been fighting the battle since 2021, and said it is now up to the government to spell the rule out clearly in the Labour Code.1
Unifor Local 177 president Samuel Deschesne said members stood outside the plant's locked gates during the lockout while some of their work was being done remotely. He said the local would not accept remote work being used to undermine its rights, that it has stood its ground since 2021 and that the fight will help protect other workers in the same situation.1
Unifor described the ruling as an important step forward in defending union rights and said changes in technology and the organization of work must go hand in hand with effective protections for workers during labour disputes.1
Prepared with reporting tools under our editorial standards. Our editorial approach.
Comments
No comments yet.